How to follow up with prospects on LinkedIn without forgetting anyone
Most deals aren't won with the first message but with the follow-up. The problem isn't knowing how to follow up: it's remembering who to follow up with, and when.
Why follow-ups get lost
On LinkedIn, a conversation where you wrote last looks just like all the others. It slides down the list as new messages arrive, and after a week it is out of sight. Nobody reminds you.
When to follow up?
- First follow-up: 3 to 5 business days after your message, with no reply.
- Second follow-up: a week later, with a new angle (a resource, a specific question).
- After that: give it some space. After two follow-ups with no reply, it's better to set the conversation aside and come back in a month or two, with a real reason.
How to follow up without being pushy
A good follow-up is short, adds something and makes it easy to reply:
Hi Claire, following up on your ERP project. Would Thursday or Friday work for a 20-minute call?
Hi Paul, I just published a case study on a migration similar to yours, it might be useful. Is this still on your radar?
Avoid a bare “just following up”: it gives no reason to reply.
A system that lets nothing slip
- Automatically spot conversations where you wrote last and have had no reply for N days.
- Group them in a single “Follow up” list, sorted by age.
- Decide for each one: follow up now, snooze until a date, or dismiss the follow-up.
DiscussIn: no more forgotten follow-ups
DiscussIn builds this “Follow up” folder for you: every conversation without a reply for 3 days (adjustable) shows up there with the number of days elapsed. You can reply with a message template, set a reminder for a specific date, or dismiss the follow-up in one click. Follow-ups older than three months are no longer suggested, so the list stays useful.
Follow up

How many times should you follow up with a prospect on LinkedIn?
Two follow-ups about a week apart is a good maximum. After that, let a month or two go by and come back with a new reason.
Can you schedule a follow-up on LinkedIn?
LinkedIn doesn't offer reminders. DiscussIn lets you set a reminder on a person or snooze the conversation: it comes back to the top of your inbox on the day you choose.
Should you follow up by message or by comment?
A private message is still the most direct. That said, a relevant comment on the person's recent post can restart the conversation naturally.
Try DiscussIn for free
7 days free, no credit card required. Then €29, one time. No subscription.